How Scary is a Plush Cthulhu, Anyway?

By Sam Gafford.

Over the last few years, an interesting development has arisen in the world of Lovecraft collecting: plush Cthulhus.

It began, as all invasions do, slowly with a line of (more or less) classic versions of Cthulhu and a few other Lovecraftian monsters in varying sizes. Then, the trend got heavier and larger. Suddenly, there was Santa Cthulhu, Men in Black Cthulhu, Superhero Cthulhu, Summer Beach Cthulhu and, perhaps the most insidiously evil of all, Elvis Cthulhu. And it didn’t stop there. Soon there were Cthulhu slippers, hats and backpacks. Then came the ultimate merchandising of all: action figures.

Since then, we have seen even more Cthulhu themed items like CTHULHU MONOPOLY, CTHULHU YAHTZEE, role playing games with Cthulhu tokens, Cthulhu hourglasses and more and more and more. Cthulhu could easily give Superman or Sherlock Holmes a challenge for highest revenue generating non-existent character and maybe Elvis as well.

Not bad for a monster that only made one brief personal appearance in a Lovecraft story.

Still, it left many of us Lovecraft fans with a bitter quandary: can something that is supposed to be mind-shatteringly terrifying be cute? And would we even want it to be?

Lovecraft himself would likely be terrified by the very concept of his creation being used to sell t-shirts, toys and plushes. He might have appreciated that Cthulhu had become something that is recognized all over the world but it’s doubtful if he would have enjoyed some of the ways that Cthulhu has been used. So we are left with debating if all these things cheapen the meaning of Cthulhu? (“Yes, Virginia, there is a Cthulhu.”)

It was not so long ago that there was practically no Lovecraft merchandise of any kind around. Probably the first big, non-book related item was the release of the classic CALL OF CTHULHU role playing game by Chaosium back in 1981. It didn’t come with any figures but, at last, one could create your own Lovecraftian adventures using a RPG system created especially for the game. (There had been an early edition of the D&D sourcebook, DEITIES AND DEMIGODS in 1980, which included a section devoted to Lovecraftian monsters and, boy, were we excited to see that back then! Honest. We really were.)

Other than Chaosium expansion sets and scenarios, it was pretty lean for Cthulhu collectibles for a number of years. Then, in the 1990s, businesses woke up to the fact that there were a whole lotta Lovecraft fans out there eager to pay anything for Cthulhu related items. This led to an explosion of items including t-shirts, metal miniatures for RPGs, models, statues and the like. Some were pretty darn good like Randy Bowen’s sculpture of Cthulhu (modeled after the one done by the young artist Wilcox in “The Call of Cthulhu”) and some were just baffling (like the Horrorclix Cthulhu).

Most of these were, for the most part, trying to keep with the monstrous nature of Cthulhu himself. All that changed with the plushes.

Almost immediately, Lovecraft fandom divided like the Red Sea. Some didn’t care about them while others felt that they demeaned the intent of Lovecraft’s work. And yet, they sold an awful lot of those plush Cthulhus.

Because I’m an old fart, I was quite amused by them and picked up some myself. They’re displayed on a shelf in my home and I get a kick out of seeing them. But I can do that because I can separate them from Lovecraft’s work. To me, they neither enhance nor detract from the stories and are just a source of mild amusement.

In 1969, a reporter visited novelist James M. Cain (DOUBLE INDEMNITY, THE POSTMAN ALWAYS RINGS TWICE and many more books) and asked if the writer was upset about what Hollywood had done to his book. His reply, “They haven’t done anything to my book. It’s right there on the shelf.” That’s a powerful statement which, at its heart, means that nothing can truly affect the original work. It remains whole and unchanged. “The Call of Cthulhu” is, in a sense, still resting undisturbed on Lovecraft’s shelf.

Those plush dolls can’t hurt Lovecraft’s work because they cannot change the words he wrote or the worlds he created. But, the one area that they can have an impact is in perception.

Lovecraft’s influence is cultural now. It is not purely limited to books. One of the most interesting realizations to come out of organizing the recent NecronomiCon conventions is our discovery that, while everyone knows Cthulhu, not everyone knows Lovecraft. The creation has surpassed the creator much in the same way that Sherlock Holmes is known far more widely than Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, the man who first created the detective.

Why this is important is because, in today’s culture, someone is less likely to first know Cthulhu as a cosmic entity whose very existence is terrifying and soul-shattering and is more likely to recognize him as a plush doll or a character that popped up on a cartoon. That’s the real shame in that some people don’t know the real Cthulhu. And, worse yet, they might think that the Cthulhu in the books is a rip-off of the toy.

Sadly, thought, there’s not all that much we can do about that. There’s no need to look down on the toys or those people who appreciate or love them. Some have even found their way to Lovecraft through them. They’re all meant to be just good fun and enjoyed with a wry chuckle every now and then.

Until, of course, a pair of Cthulhu slippers comes alive and starts chewing on your feet!

(This post was written by Sam Gafford. Check out his excellent William Hope Hodgson blog here.)

7 responses to “How Scary is a Plush Cthulhu, Anyway?

  1. I’ve had Cthulhu plushies since they first came out. They’re cute and silly, with lots of memories attached to them. Would they help cope with the insanity of seeing Cthulhu rise from the deeps? Doubtful at best 😉

  2. The cutification(?) of Cthulhu is a mixed bag – then again, maybe its part of his plan. The more people who think of him, the sooner he can come and destroy us all…lol.

    When our highly precocious granddaughter (I know – all grandparents say that. What follows will prove it) was three, I bought her a lime green crocheted Cthulhu on Etsy – basically a plushie octopus with one big eye. I didn’t tell her what it was. She loved it. Shortly thereafter, someone asked her what it was. She said it was a “soul-sucker”.

    Fluffy bunny? Maybe. And then again…

  3. My friend, Katy Sozaeva, who I met online on Goodreads, and – as far as I know – was a member of the Lovecraft eZine, sent me the green plush Cthulhu shown above as a combination ‘Get Well/Christmas present’ after I was hospitalized when my lower body collapsed requiring emergency surgery to repair my L4 – L5 disc regions in my back. That was 2 1/2 years ago. During that time Katy was suffering from cancer. I live in the SF area of California, Katy in Athens, Georgia. She passed away last year, August 23rd, 2016, 2 days before my 48th birthday. I was never able to meet her in person.

    Katy was a wonderful gal, book editor (even for some Lovecraftian fiction I believe), having created and managed the popular booksite, Now Is Gone, where she did author interviews, reviews and numerous book giveaways. She helped turn my life around twice, once while handicapped and wheelchair-bound. She was a shining light in this twilit world. I miss her, her brilliant mind, her sense of humor, her book suggestions, and her unique outlook on life. I named my green Cthulhu plush after her, KATY CTHULHU, who now has a permanent place by my pillows on my bed (along with my 2 stuffed animal spirit whales, Happy & Bloopy) to keep me comfort during sleep and while reading, and to help me remember her.

    • That’s a wonderful story. Thank you so much for sharing it. I hope your health has taken a positive turn. Katy sounds like she was a wonderful person.

      • Thank you, Mike. She was. We spoke of your site several tiimes btw. She loved it so I expect she must have been a regular visitor. My health has improved greatly and can now walk unassisted. Katy Cthulhu is still at the head of my bed protecting me from bad dreams however! : D

  4. I have a Plush Cthulhu. I love it. I also have a Funko Pop! Cthulhu and a Cthulhu Idol I handmade, plus a neat Cthulhu poster art I got at a con. Two out of those four things are cute. I definitely do not think making the Mythos “cute” detracts from the real Mythos proper. It’s much the same way there is actually a small subset of newer Mythos fans who pull a “Draco in Leather Pants” type thing with Nyarlathotep-as-human-form – it just happens. You are going to see it. It’s a thing that commonly happens. It’s not ruining the Mythos when it’s just one of the many, many ways people enjoy the Mythos.

    I think the cutifying of Cthulhu is part of the way people deal with the concepts behind cosmic horror. People often try to defang things that spook them, or otherwise make them less intimidating. That does not mean they’re not still scary concepts. If anything, I think Cthulhu itself is overrated, and prefer more varied Lovecraftian deities that get less attention. They’re way more fun when roleplayed in CoC, and way more fun to tinker with.

    tl;dr – I’m the kind of Lovecraft fan that would totally, and does, have a cute plush King in Yellow right next to a mock poster advertising the play and my Hastur idol, along with my absolutely creepy King in Yellow cosplay that terrified half my neighborhood last Halloween. Cute is fun. Don’t fear the cute. 🙂

  5. I have a plush Cthulhu like the one in the illustration above. I used to keep on my side of the bed but it apparently didn’t like it there because I kept finding it in my side of the closet. I mentioned this to my wife and she just snorted and said He was better off there. Speaking of Lovecraft merchandise, I had a embroidered “Miskatonic University” cap that I finally wore out. I’ve since replaced it with one that just says “Miskatonic” in vinyl lettering. I also have a business casual button down collar Innsmouth Yacht Club shirt.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s